solongshrimp's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[The Molecular Level]

Instrumentals need to invariably build up to a solo, or a dynamic climax, and I was slightly disappointed that there was nothing like that in the changes. I just kept waiting for a melody to guide the music but nope. Also while your guitar tone was totally bitchin' the synthesized drums are very obvious when you blast the double bass pedal without changing the note velocities to simulate performance. But I mean if this had lyrics and a real drummer it would be a tight ass song man.

Xenogenocide responds:

I'm sorry there wasn't a solo. :(

[5/4 to the floor]

The buildup was paced pretty well, but no matter how you slice it the digital guitar midi that comes with audio editing programs is shitty.

ElectroGorrilaBear responds:

The electric guitar in a alot of ways was purposeful , and instead of trying too hard to get it to sound good i rather went with the opposite of completely processing them to a point of being their own sound with elements of guitar :P rather then the other way round , however yes if going for great guitar noises it can be difficult even with correct midi notation.Thank you for the review *OH! OH! AH AH!*

[Light Of The Diamond]

It's very pretty, but melodically I feel it could've gone into something more dynamic.

SMJ responds:

Seems to be the general opinion of the piece. Within context the next track builds up more. But I agree it maybe could have done with a bit more dynamics within the track. Thanks for the feedback!

[Angel's Arp]

This is dope as fuck.

putzpie responds:

Hell yeah man thanks

[Wave (Jobim cover)]

Good playing but you're description is a list of excuses as to why you didn't just tune you're guitar.

phosphorusprocedure responds:

It's that situation where if I tune it so it sounds good down below, it would off up top.

My acoustic is like that too.

I was gonna have my friend at some shop take a look at both, but he was out of town the past week.

I know, more excuses right?

I should probably edit the description and have it just say 'lol I'm lazy, here you go' but that seemed kinda snarky.

I'd buy one of those intonation neck-bender things but I'm afraid I'd break my guitar or fuck it up worse.

What can I say, man? I'm neurotic. The guitar's the least of my problems. Heehee

[Air Ripple]

Reminds me of Dark Cloud for some reason, fucking awesome.

spikel responds:

Hey thanks dude :D

[Burial Gates]

As an instrumental to keep entertaining someone it needs to have some lead instrument drawing focus where vocals would be or else non musicians get bored fast. If this had lyrics or like a Steve Vai-esque lead over top of the middle sections it'd be dope as shit.

Throughdarkness responds:

Thank you, and I definitely agree. I have all the intent to eventually have vocals on this track. I am however not a good vocalist. I am currently writing lyrics in hopes to stumble across someone with some talent. I guess I could write some leads for those parts too, but really, I'm not a phenomenal guitarist and would rather not ruin it. I just cannot execute my idea of great leads unfortunately.

[Stone Fish]

Pretty rad melodically, it just felt like it was building up to something but just never got there. I could see this in a soundtrack but as a standalone song it needs some sort of dynamic climax.

Intrapath responds:

I hear ya, I definitely see what you mean. Thanks for leaving a review! :)